Persona 3&4 for PS2 question? 10 points best answer!?

May be...

So I've been looking at the reviews for Persona 3&4 and they're pretty tied...I heard 3 had better characters but 4 had a better game play stimulation.

So which do you like better, Persona 3 or 4 and why?



*please only answer if you've played both of them before.

Persona 4 beats Persona 3 in almost every aspect of the game. Gameplay improvements, great story & characters, level variety, voice actors etc. And I do believe Persona 4 is longer.



Persona 4 also has this weather system that I loved (I don't want to spoil, but it's cool). P4 was "funner" while P3 was serious.



So for now, go with P4, but *make sure at one point to get both*.

I prefer Persona 4. I don't care about how the characters are like, but the story is very good in Persona 4. It makes sense. There's a killer who throws the victim into the TV and Main Character try to safe them. At least it is easy to learn. But what do you think about story in Persona 3? It is complicated, but it really doesn't make sense. Fighting shadow will make the dark hour disappear? They finally realize that they've done is wrong. So, why would they spend a whole year to do something worthless? The other thing that doesn't make sense is Main Character is Death Incarnation. How possible we play with the Death? Really ridiculous.



However, I love both of them. But I choose Persona 4 because of its story

i've never played them before but my brother plays them and he loves both 3-4 a lot. So it must be great